Tomorrow’s edition of the Los Angeles Times includes a feature by Harriet Ryan on the Global Antiques props sold on eBay by Auction Depot LA, Auction Shop USA, and Historic Souvenirs. The full story can be read online at latimes.com – “Internet citizen posses investigate some sellers” – also archived below:
Internet citizen posses investigate some sellers
Auctions of supposed Hollywood memorabilia on eBay provoke an angry response from some buyers.
By Harriet Ryan, Los Angeles Times Staff Writer
July 23, 2008
The pieces of Hollywood history were priced to move, even by the discount standards of EBay. Ten bucks put a bidder in the running for a dagger purportedly used in the filming of “Gone With the Wind,” a decanter from “I Love Lucy” and a birdhouse from “Lord of the Rings.” Bidding for other memorabilia, including a vase said to be from “Casablanca,” opened at only 99 cents.
The bargain-basement prices offered by a Marina del Rey antiques dealer this spring sparked two reactions online: furious bidding and deep suspicion. As fans drove the prices up — the dagger sold for $713 — a group of seasoned collectors from across the country became convinced the items were phony.
“The most obvious fakes I’d ever seen,” pronounced James Tumblin, a Hawaiian who said he owns the world’s largest collection of “Gone With the Wind” memorabilia.
Frustrated by the lack of response from police, the collectors became a sort of Internet posse. They traced the dagger to a factory in modern-day Japan, the birdhouse to a Big Lots and the vase to the former West Germany — a country whose existence postdated “Casablanca” by seven years.
They used their findings to warn away other bidders and lobby EBay to shut down online stores selling the dealer’s merchandise.
“I really felt people had a right to know,” said Jennifer Henderson, a vintage clothing collector who said she and her husband, Bryce, spent more hours “than I am comfortable admitting” investigating the dealer, Global Antiques.
EBay suspended the two Culver City consignment stores that listed the items last month. One of the consignment stores, AuctionDepotLA, has since closed.
Neither Global Antiques owner Greg Jones nor representatives of the consignment shops returned calls. No charges have been brought against Jones, Global Antiques or any of the stores involved. In a statement, EBay said privacy policies prevented it from disclosing the reasons it shuttered the auctions of those selling Global Antiques’ merchandise.
Auction fraud is the most commonly reported crime online, according to the federal Internet Crime Complaint Center, also known as the IC3.
As local police and auction houses struggle to keep up, citizens are increasingly stepping in to the gap and making what amount to cyber citizen arrests.
“Our speculation is that the posse mentality can take care of these situations faster than the host can,” said Craig Butterworth, a spokesman for the National White Collar Crime Center, which jointly administers the IC3 with the FBI.
In some cases, law enforcement encourages citizen investigators. Det. Alex Moreno of the LAPD’s computer crimes unit said legwork by victims can make a case more attractive to officers who prioritize “voluminous” complaints of auction fraud by the number of victims and the amount of money lost.
“I tell them to see if they can find other people who got scammed because then we will be able to show a pattern of conduct,” Moreno said.
He said the angry bidders feel energized by their amateur detective work.
“People are savvy, especially when they’ve been wronged,” he said.
Culver City police investigated the sales after being contacted by the Hendersons and a Kansas woman who said the nearly $15,000 in “I Love Lucy” memorabilia she bought was a hodgepodge of junk with no connection to the television show.
Det. Kirk Newman said the listings seemed obviously questionable. He noted that a disclaimer warned that the items were “not for investment or resale purposes.”
“If it was truly the collectible they say it is, why would it be listed for $25?” he said.
Still, he said, he determined that the consignment stores in his jurisdiction, AuctionDepotLA and AuctionShopUSA, had done nothing illegal.
“These people don’t know what they are selling. Someone just comes in, gives them something and they put it online,” he said. Newman interviewed Jones, who said that he got the items through connections at movie studios. Global Antiques was in Marina del Rey, out of Newman’s jurisdiction, and he closed the case.
It was a frustrating response for the collectors monitoring the sales and those who believed that they were duped.
“It’s like pulling teeth to get anyone to do anything,” said Debbie Nickerson, the “I Love Lucy” buyer from Kansas.
She had bought almost 300 Global Antiques items when she received an e-mail about a glass decanter she won with a $36 bid.
“It said the decanter was manufactured for the bicentennial in 1976, so how could it have been a prop on ‘I Love Lucy’?” she said.
A film prop collector from suburban Sacramento, Jason DeBord, began cataloging questionable merchandise from Global Antiques in April on his website, Original Prop Blog. DeBord, a Realtor, posted e-mails from customers as well as his research. He began tracking the items on a spreadsheet. The sales were small but numerous.
“It averaged out to a thousand dollars a day,” he said.
After learning that items identical to those advertised as Hollywood memorabilia were turning up in TJ Maxx and Big Lots stores, DeBord posted a map showing the proximity of both chains to the Culver City consignment shops.
Jennifer Henderson said she e-mailed winning bidders and directed them to DeBord’s blog.
“Some were dubious of what I was doing, but a lot of them were grateful,” she said.
EBay has a policy against third parties interfering with auctions. The company asks users to e-mail its fraud department with concerns. The collectors investigating Global Antiques said they did so, but were displeased with the automated responses they received.
On June 19, a lawyer representing Jones wrote a letter to Bryce Henderson demanding that he stop the “overwrought and relentless campaign to discredit and damage” Global Antiques and the consignment stores.
Reached by phone, the attorney, Edward Schloss, said he was hired only to write the letter and had no comment on the fraud allegations other than noting that police determined no crime occurred.
Darren Julien, the owner of Julien’s Auctions, a Los Angeles company that has sold memorabilia including the puffy shirt from “Seinfeld” and Alfred Hitchcock’s passport, said one of his clients spent $6,000 on Global Antiques items.
“The people on the really high-end scale tend to be more savvy. It’s the people who want to get into collecting, who can spend maybe $5 to $10,000 who get burnt,” he said.
Below are the Global Antiques articles published on the Original Prop Blog:
- Gone With The Wind, Global Antiques, and Auction Depot LA
- Global Antiques, Auction Depot LA – Reader Experience With “Original” Casablanca Prop
- I Love Lucy, Global Antiques, and Auction Depot LA
- Thomas Edison, Global Antiques, and Auction Depot LA
- Mark Twain, Global Antiques, and Auction Depot LA
- Al Capone, Global Antiques, and Auction Depot LA
- Gone With The Wind, Global Antiques, and Auction Depot LA – “Original Dagger Sword”
- The Lord of the Rings, Global Antiques, and Auction Depot LA
- I Love Lucy, Global Antiques, and Auction Depot LA – Silver Creamer
- Auction Depot LA & Global Antiques: I Love Lucy, Harmony Rose, and T.J. Maxx – Part 1
- Auction Depot LA & Global Antiques: I Love Lucy, Harmony Rose, and T.J. Maxx – Part 2
- Auction Depot L.A. & Global Antiques Entertainment Memorabilia – Two Weeks of eBay Listing/Sales Activity
- Auction Depot LA, Auction Shop USA, Global Antiques: The Lord of the Rings and “Big Lots!”
- “Global Antiques” Memorabilia Listings Pulled From eBay
- “Classic” Film & Television Prop and Wardrobe eBay Sellers
- “Global Antiques” Returns To eBay: “Historic Souvenirs”
- Auction Shop USA Update: Private eBay Feedback Profile
- “Auction Depot LA” & “Global Antiques” Update: Buyer Leaves Mass Negative Feedback, Cites “Criminal Investigation”
- “Global Antiques”, “Auction Depot LA”, “Auction Shop USA”: Customer Comments
- “Global Antiques” Culver City Map: eBay Seller Storefronts, “Big Lots!”, “T.J. Maxx”
- “Historic Souvenirs” Cancels “Global Antiques” eBay Auctions; “Auction Depot LA” Update
- “Auction Depot LA”, “Auction Shop USA”: “Not a Registered User” (NARU) Status on eBay
- “Global Antiques” Update from Deb
Jason De Bord